Secondary Science Teaching for English Learners: Developing Supportive and Responsive Contexts for Sense-Making and Language Development

August 2017 – Volume 21, Number 2

Secondary Science Teaching for English Learners: Developing Supportive
and Responsive Contexts for Sense-Making and Language Development

Author: Edward G. Lyon, Sara Tolbert, Patricia Stoddart, Jorge Solís, & George C. Bunch (2016)  
Publisher: Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield
Pages ISBN Price
258 pages 978-1-4422-3126-9 $36.00 USD

Secondary Science Teaching for English Learners: Developing Supportive and Responsive Contexts for Sense-Making and Language Development describes the changing student landscape in the United States and the need to address the linguistic needs differences due to the changing demographics within the nation. The Secondary Science Teaching with English Language and Literacy Acquisition (SSTELLA) project aims to prepare the next generation of secondary science teachers and provide them with tools to support teaching science to English language learners (ELLs). The project aims to promote science learning, and secondly it seeks to facilitate literacy development in the sciences.

The book’s primary target audience is new secondary science teachers, but it could also be relevant for experienced practicing teachers. SSTELLA practices align to meet current Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS; 2013) and Common Core State Standards (CCSS; 2017) curriculum objectives for secondary school science teachers while simultaneously addressing the needs of ELLs in school systems in the United States.

This ten-chapter book addresses the need for secondary school science teachers to make science lessons more contextualized. The three sections comprising the book are: Foundations for Language, Literacy and Science Integration; Supportive and Responsive Science Teaching Practices; and Applying SSTELLA Practices to Curricular and Assessment Planning. The first part of the book places the need for an integrated approach to learning science and developing literacy for English language learners through the discipline of science. The next section introduces the SSTELLA framework and provides details on the four main strategies that provide understanding of the context and their connection to CCSS and the NGSS. The final part of the book demonstrates the SSTELLA framework with an actual science lesson.

Part One, Foundations for Language, Literacy and Science Integration, consists of two chapters which aim to make science education more relevant for the general population and applicable to the diverse learners in secondary school classrooms. Chapter One provides the reader with the context for understanding the changes in education as a result of current NGSS across the U.S. This chapter also helps the reader understand the need for learners to achieve content area literacy, which in turn fosters engagement with the discipline. The second chapter describes how teachers can build engagement in the classroom environment and defines how English language learners in the secondary content classroom can be more diverse than ELLs in the primary grades.

Part Two, Supportive and Responsive Science Teaching Practices, consists of five chapters that explain the SSTELLA framework. This section also contextualizes science through scientific meaning making, scientific discourse practices, and literacy development within the discipline of science. Text boxes within the chapters include examples for the reader to analyze to help them interact with the material presented in each chapter. These text boxes are useful for identifying the contribution SSTELLA makes to existing practices.

Part Three, Applying SSTELLA Practices to Curricular and Assessment Planning, comprises three chapters which address using SSTELLA practices in actual classrooms. Chapters Eight and Nine include a lesson about the antibiotic resistance of Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), which shows readers how teachers can engage students in the concept of natural selection and how species change over time. Chapter eight introduces the lesson, and chapter nine deconstructs it by explaining the reasoning behind the choices for the focus in the lesson.

The final chapter focuses on assessment practices using SSTELLA, addressing how multiple-choice tests, commonly used in content area classrooms, actually put ELLs at a disadvantage due to unfamiliar vocabulary or cultural contexts in the questions (Kachchaf, Noble, Rosebery, O’Connor, Warren, & Wang, 2016). The chapter also includes a diagram presenting how learning objectives and small formative assessments can ultimately lead students to attain the big idea being presented through each of the smaller learning objectives.

The book presents activities and examples grounded in the current research for science education, as well as literacy education for ELLs. The included sample lesson using the SSTELLA framework demonstrates SSTELLA practices in action helping the reader to better understand the subtle differences SSTELLA provides. The classroom discourse examples provided in the second section (chapters three to seven) help the reader see how SSTELLA and non-SSTELLA practices are similar but not the same when it comes to engaging students in the science classroom. Reading through the examples helps one realize that SSTELLA is more than just engaging students in discussion, it is about providing a personal context for the science being explored and helping the student become more engaged in the scientific concepts being presented.

Aside from the partialities involved in the SSTELLA project, this book is an excellent resource for new science teachers entering the teaching profession. Current research practices support the methods described in the book for both science and literacy education for ELLs. The book is also useful for established teachers to reflect on their own teaching practices through helping them become aware of the literacy needs of their ELLs in the content classroom along with demonstrating SSTELLA practices. Secondary Science Teaching for English Learners: Developing Supportive and Responsive Learning Contexts for Sense-making and Language Development will provide practitioners with a useful tool to recognize and adjust to the importance of literacy instruction within the content areas and not just teaching the content material. Implementing the types of lessons and practices outlined in the book will also help ELLs transition to science content and may even provide them with the opportunity to pursue science, technology, engineering or mathematics (STEM) careers where they are highly under-represented.

References

“SSTELLA” BOOK REVIEW 3
Common Core State Standards Initiative (2017). Common Core State Standards for English language arts & literacy in history/social studies, science and technical subjects. Retrieved from: http://www.corestandards.org.

Kachchaf, R., Noble, T., Rosebery, A., O'Connor, C., Warren, B., & Wang, Y. (2016). Acloser look at linguistic complexity: Pinpointing individual linguistic features of science multiple-choice items associated with English language learner performance. Bilingual Research Journal, 39(2), 152-166.

Lyon, E. G., Tolbert, S., Solís, J., Stoddart, P., & Bunch, G. C. (2016). Secondary science teaching for English learners: Developing supportive and responsive learning contexts for sense-making and language development. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Next Generation Science Standards (2013). Improving science education through three dimensional learning. Retrieved from: http://www.nextgenscience.org.

Reviewed by
Anna Karin Roo
Washington State University
<anna.rooatmarkwsu.edu>

© Copyright rests with authors. Please cite TESL-EJ appropriately.
Editor’s Note: The HTML version contains no page numbers. Please use the PDF version of this article for citations.